I recently received a submission from Nancy R. one of Positive Space’s readers. The submission is her first hand experience with sitepoint contests / 99designs. I thought that she had some great wisdom to share with the community based on her experience with the contests. she states that “Artist’s need to wake up and realize that their unique talents are just that, unique.” which I completely agree with. I agreed to share her opinion with the readers because I think it contains some great wisdom about the dangers of spec work. So without further introduction here is the full account of her experience:
Nancy’s Experience With 99Designs / Sitepoint Contests
Why I recently removed two designs I had on sitepoint, which were 4 starred, and termed “brilliant” from the contest holder. After my ego was stroked for a few days, I decided that I just could not sell myself short. I put my blood, sweat and tears into developing this design, it took over a week, I am sure. I am going to keep it for MY DREAM, I have of eventually selling my work as posters, with my copyright name and reap the benefits of my hard work, and not selling my work, for a cheap price. Hey artists, don’t forget to deduct taxes from the contest awarded price, electricity, cost of hardware and software products, and your talent, perhaps college cost. I am done with site point. It is a place where the artist is certainly being mocked, behind their backs and how many designs have been ripped off by those CH’s who don’t really want to pay at all but use an idea. How about the payed for designs that will be used on merchandise, will the unsuspecting artist ever know how much money they lost in possible royalties? I suspect, most of them are young and desperate. I can say this, since I am 54 years old and experienced. I used to be a designer for a Fortune 500 company, and had my own small business years ago. Anyway, I would suggest that every creative out there should purchase the book, “Pricing and Ethical Guidelines
” by THE ARTISTS GUILD GUIDEBOOK, to get educated on the only other important aspect of being a creative and that is the pricing end of it all. I think, after these inexperienced artists read this book, they will have their eyes wide open. Also, you can purchase a used book on Amazon for less money. I always purchase used books and the conditions of each have always been just fine. Well, that is all for now. Get educated!
Why not share something too?
If you have something that you would like to share with the Positive Space community be sure to check out the contribute page!
July 25th, 2008 at 11:49 am
Ya know, there’s a reason you hear phrases like “starving artist”. Nobody has ever heard the phrase “starving lawyer” or “starving CEO”.
If you’re going to enter shitty Sitepoint and 99design contests, why bother leaning design at all? Why bother going to school for design and fine art? Why spend the money on the materials and take the time to learn the software and spend the hours and hours honing your skills if it will all be lost on some crappy contest that pays a few hundred bucks? Save yourself the time, money and frustration by getting a job at McDonald’s instead. Hey, at least you’ll be able to feed yourself.
These contests and spec work read like a bad business proposal. Any lawyer or CEO would turn shit like that down in a second. That is the difference between the artist and the lawyer or CEO. As long as you continue to perpetuate that difference, you will be on the bottom of the foodchain.
You can retain a lawyer for several thousand dollars to help you with criminal charges. He may, for an additional hourly fee, represent you at trial. You may still get convicted and sent to jail. The lawyer will still bill you for his services, as he should. If you told your lawyer that you would only pay him if you didn’t go to jail, he would laugh in your face and throw you out of his office. Take a hint, be like the lawyer, not like the starving artist.
August 3rd, 2008 at 10:40 am
Nancy,
Thank you for sharing! You are one hundred percent right!
I have the same mixed feeling about Google Ads. The moment you add Google Ads to your web site, it looses its personality. Do you really make money with Google Ads? Nop!
August 3rd, 2008 at 12:26 pm
Gale,
Adsense can make a site loose personality, however it depends on how they are treated and whether you are just looking to make money on the site. That is why I only run one adsense block on this site, and I do not place them within the content of the site. However that being said, I have been able to make money off the ads, however it is very little and only really allows me to sustain and evolve the site.